Sharable/ private writing
• Shared writing is that which is accepted by the institution and therefore it is limiting because it has a form and guidelines which deem certain things wrong/right. Private writing has no boundaries, a person can write any way they want without fearing rejection or that they will be told their writing is wrong.
how did these boundaries get set?
• School teaches students that they need to write a certain way/ that there are expectations of what their writing should look like.
• Journal writing is often described as personal writing as is informal. When applied to the classroom the journal writing consists of messy drafts/ideas but it is still being limited by the institution because there are still things that are considered inappropriate to write about.
how do those boundaries empower and limit me as a writer?
• There are two voices and one feels more of my own that the other. Sharable writing (academic writing)
• now more papers are asking me to react to an essay or an idea but usually the assignment was to regurgitate what I had already read in order to prove that I understood it. Essentially the assignment was to read a text, understand it by changing it to your language, then write a paper using a mixture of the language from the text and your own language. Yu had to show you picked up new language/ a new discourse. Join the conversation. However, the student is not as familiar with the discourse so they're essentially a scribe wielding a long sword that they can barely pick up let alone wield in battle.
• personal writing becomes more difficult because I'm used to writing academic papers and so de-conditioning myself to be able to write freely without censoring my thoughts is a wall that needs to be demolished before I can sit down and write in my own voice.
Marian MacCurdy "From Trauma to Writing"
Anderson and MacCurdy say that professors of writing have tended
to marginalize writing that deals with trauma because it "challenges
[their] practical, political, and theoretical assumptions about the power,
place, and purpose of writing" (2). This also alienates the writers of
such texts in favor of more controlled discourses of the academy" (2).
"Excluding life writing limits what people can do with
words" (38).
Sandra Perl "Felt Sense"
James Pennebaker "Opening Up"
Marian MacCurdy "From Trauma to Writing"
Duffy
Chamberlain
I have sections of my transcript but I think I have too many excerpts and I'm not sure which ones I will choose to analyze more deeply in order to include it in the paper.